HS2

12.09.18

East Coast fiasco: MPs decide who is to blame for ‘overoptimistic’ franchise

Virgin, Stagecoach and the DfT all share blame for the quick failure of the East Coast franchise earlier this year – with the first two drafting up a financially risky bid with very little resilience, and the latter setting unrealistic benchmarks in the ITT document and encouraging overbidding.

These are the findings of MPs in the Transport Committee, which today set out the conclusion of its investigation into the service’s collapse – the third time in just over a decade this has happened, and yet another blemish in the franchise’s troubled history.

MPs accepted that the Virgin Trains East Coast (VTEC) franchise had successful day-to-day operations, reflected in the high rates of passenger satisfaction which ranked it amongst the top-performing TOCs in the country.

But the operating surplus generated was not enough to fully cover the premium obligations it contractually had with the DfT. To cover revenue shortfalls, VTEC had to forego the £165m parent company guarantee it committed to the DfT when the deal was let; by the end of January this year, the last parent company support was drawn down and the franchise went into “technical default.”

VTEC’s role: prime responsibility

“The latest ICEC franchise therefore failed because the revenue projections underpinning the VTEC bid were over-optimistic and it simply ran out of money,” the report said. “Revenue fell short of expectations from day one and passenger growth that was anticipated never materialised.”

The committee argued that franchises should be able to withstand normal fluctuations in the economic cycle; the fact that VTEC didn’t is indicative of the fact that Virgin and Stagecoach built very little resilience into their bid, with “wholly inadequate” assessment of risk.

“This was naïve, and it should have been more aware of the financial risks involved, particularly given the history of this franchise and Stagecoach and Virgin’s long history of bidding for and running franchises in this country. We conclude that Stagecoach and Virgin bear prime responsibility for the failure of this franchise,” the report stated.

The DfT’s role: complicit

The department must also take responsibility for the fiasco, MPs said: it encouraged overbidding by setting unrealistic benchmarks in the ITT document, and the bid process itself “lacked the necessary boundaries to temper overoptimistic bidding.”

In stark contrast to what was said during the inquiry, the DfT’s financial stress-testing of the bids was not robust enough, the report said, adding: “If the DfT had conducted appropriate due diligence and identified weaknesses in the assumptions underpinning the bid, it may not have been in this position today.”

The committee’s chair, Lilian Greenwood MP, commented further: “The secretary of state pointed the finger at Stagecoach and Virgin for getting their bids wrong, but the department is not blameless.

“Following the failure of the East Coast line, there is talk that the prime minister has ordered a major review of rail franchising—we await more details. However, if this or any other future partnership arrangement is truly going to deliver a step-change in performance for the passenger, more fundamental reform of our railways is required.”

165 Chris Grayling c. Dominic Lipinski, PA Wire

Network Rail’s role: in the clear

In contrast to what Sir Richard Branson claimed, the Transport Committee determined that Network Rail does not actually bear any responsibility for the franchise failure.

To date, the organisation has provided all of the infrastructure upgrades that it had formally committed to when the franchise was let, the report argued. Other upgrades were assumed to occur by the DfT and VTEC in order to deliver an enhanced 2019 timetable, but there was no formal funding commitment to this.

“While Network Rail’s performance in managing the ECML had not been up to standard, and this clearly undermined franchise performance, it was not on a scale that led to VTEC defaulting on their contract,” MPs commented.

East Coast Partnership

Regarding the East Coast Partnership – what Chris Grayling has called “the first of the new generation of long-term regional partnerships bringing together the operation of track and train” – the committee said plans are unlikely to deliver everything the DfT is expecting.

“Even now, there is no concrete plan, nor timescales, for the interim operator of this franchise,” explained Greenwood. “From our inquiry, we cannot be sure, and cannot reassure passengers or public, that the arrangements for the East Coast Partnership will more successfully overcome the systemic difficulties presented by the current set-up.”

While greater joint-working and clearer lines of accountability does have the potential to improve services, the mechanics and complexity of the current financial and regulatory environment “has meant that all previous attempts to establish deep alliances have not worked.”

“This proposal also risks adding an additional layer of complexity to this part of the network. Passengers will ultimately bear the risk if this proposal goes wrong,” the report concluded.

Organisations react

In response to the report, a Stagecoach Group spokesman said the company has operated railways on behalf of the government for more than 20 years using the same “bold, ambitious and meticulous approach which delivered strong success in the past.”

“As the committee makes absolutely clear, there was no incentive to deliberately overbid and there was no taxpayer bailout in the unfortunate premature end to the contract,” he noted.

“Most importantly, we are pleased the committee has supported our positive suggestions to reform franchising, including more appropriate risk-sharing, making the system more accountable and robust, and ensuring that the customers and communities who rely on the railway see promised infrastructure and service improvements in full and on time.”

A DfT spokesperson added that the department has introduced new measures to deter overbidding and improved its financial modelling and stress-testing. “Bids are now assessed with a greater emphasis on overall value for the passenger,” they continued.

Anthony Smith, chief executive of Transport Focus, told media that having more stability in the underlying East Coast contract between government and the train company will help achieve the things that matter most to passengers: the quality of services and the day-to-day performance, "whether it is punctuality, value for money, the cleanliness of the train or levels of crowding.”

Comments

There are no comments. Why not be the first?

Add your comment

 

rail technology magazine tv

more videos >

latest rail news

Network Rail’s subsidiary secures systems integrator contract in Australia

14/12/2018Network Rail’s subsidiary secures systems integrator contract in Australia

The Australian subsidiary of Network Rail Consulting has been named as the systems integrator for the Digital Systems Program in Sydney by Transp... more >
Infrastructure giant Amey to be sold to private equity firm in new year

14/12/2018Infrastructure giant Amey to be sold to private equity firm in new year

 Infrastructure giant Amey is expected to be sold to a private equity firm in the new year, according to reports. The Financial Times b... more >
HS2 and Crossrail suppliers admit to running ‘illegal cartel’ for 7 years

14/12/2018HS2 and Crossrail suppliers admit to running ‘illegal cartel’ for 7 years

Two UK rail suppliers to major projects such as HS1, HS2, and Crossrail have admitted to operating an illegal cartel for almost seven years with ... more >

editor's comment

23/01/2018Out with the old...

Despite a few disappointing policy announcements, especially for the electrification aficionados amongst us, 2017 was, like Darren Caplan writes on page 20, a year generally marked by positive news for the rail industry. We polished off the iconic Ordsall Chord (p32), hit some solid milestones on Thameslink (p40), progressed on ambitious rolling stock orders (p16), and finally started moving forward on HS2 (p14) ‒ paving the way for a New Ye... read more >

last word

Encouraging youngsters to be safe on the railway

Encouraging youngsters to be safe on the railway

This summer, Arriva Group's CrossCountry and the Scout Association joined to launch a new partnership to promote rail safety among young people. Chris Leech MBE, business community manager at the... more > more last word articles >

'the sleepers' daily blog

Spotlight on Coventry Very Light Rail

27/11/2018Spotlight on Coventry Very Light Rail

Olivia Brown, business development officer at Warwick Manufacturing Group (WMG), an academic department of the University of Warwick, outlines the four exciting projects currently taking place as part of the Coventry Very Light Rail (VLR)  programme. In RTM’s June/July issue, readers were introduced to the concept of VLR and th... more >
read more blog posts from 'the sleeper' >

comment

Passenger safety: Respect the edge

27/11/2018Passenger safety: Respect the edge

Claire Coward, communications lead at the RSSB, discusses her organisation’s latest passenger safety campaign. Incidents at the platfo... more >
Night Tube: The twilight economy

27/11/2018Night Tube: The twilight economy

Dr David Lutton, executive director of economy and tax at London First, argues that the capital’s night-time economy is just starting its j... more >
Monitoring the performance of earthworks

27/11/2018Monitoring the performance of earthworks

Dr Joel Smethurst, associate professor in geotechnical engineering, and Professor William Powrie, professor of geotechnical engineering, both of ... more >
Introducing iPort

20/11/2018Introducing iPort

Steve Freeman, managing director of iPort Rail, introduces the UK’s newest inland freight terminal. The UK’s newest inland rail ... more >

rail industry focus

View all News

interviews

HS2 train race: making the case

20/11/2018HS2 train race: making the case

Bombardier and Hitachi’s commitment to providing the best HS2 rolling stock pitch to the government was signified with the launch of their ... more >