Rail franchises operators & contracts

21.11.16

Abellio accepts ScotRail failings but apportions blame to government contract

Abellio has insisted it has “no problem” with competing for a public sector body for the ScotRail franchise, but emphasised that regardless of what type of operator runs the franchise, they still do it to a “tightly specified” contract determined by ministers.

The company’s claims came after the Scottish transport minister, Humza Yousaf, suggested that the ScotRail could lose its contract if its performance doesn’t improve. He warned there could be “very, very serious consequences” if Abellio fails to fix problems with ScotRail’s performance, and said he would be tracking the franchise’s performance daily.

Abellio has issued an improvement plan to try to resolve the problems on ScotRail, but the Scottish government has said it stands ready to take over the franchise through a new public sector body if either it or the operator decides to terminate the contract.

Responding to Yousaf’s remarks today, Charlotte Twyning, director of policy, strategy and communications for Abellio UK, said: “There is nothing new in discussions about a public sector bid for Scotland’s railways, and we have no problem competing with public bids.”

While she did acknowledge ScotRail Alliance’s performance wasn’t good enough, Twyning also apportioned blame to the other parties.

“It should be recognised that half of the rail industry is already nationalised in the form of Network Rail and any operator that runs the ScotRail franchise - public or private - does so to a tightly specified Scottish government contract, which means that ministers set fares and essentially determine how many seats are available and therefore how much overcrowding exists across the network,” she added.

“We acknowledge that the performance of the ScotRail Alliance is not good enough, but we are working hard with our clients – Transport Scotland and the Scottish government – to make the changes necessary to improve the service to rail passengers. We are also encouraging Network Rail in particular to raise its game.

“However, rail passengers are better served by organisations and individuals collaborating in customers’ interests and not their own, and we encourage all parties to do so.”

Today, rail union RMT revealed it has written to Yousaf requesting “urgent talks” on a plan to bring ScotRail into public ownership.

Earlier this month, the minister also called for Network Rail in Scotland to be devolved after an independent report criticised it for allowing crucial improvement projects to go over budget.

(Image c. Danny Lawson from PA Images)

Have you got a story to tell? Would you like to become an RTM columnist? If so, click here.

Comments

Neil Palmer   21/11/2016 at 17:11

Typical SNP government, can't make up their minds. They want to stay in Europe, but now they're talking of nationalizing the railway, which of course is strictly against EU law. You can be sure of another thing, if the RMT and other unions think it's a good idea, it isn't (except for the unions own narrow politically motivated interests).

Mikeb   21/11/2016 at 20:50

Neil. It is my understanding that it is against EU law for a country to operate a nationalised rail network - without any privately-run competition. In this regard however, SNCF have been doing just that for years and have continued to ignore requests by Brussels to open up the French network to private operators. Also the UK government "nationalised" (albeit temporarily) the East Coast franchise under the title of Directly Operated Railway.

Noam Bleicher   22/11/2016 at 11:01

Neil, it is in no way illegal to run a public sector railway company under EU law. Every other country in the EU has a public sector operator running most services. You may have heard of DB, SNCF, SNCB in Belgium, NS in the Netherlands, RENFE in Spain, FS in Italy, DSB in Denmark, OBB in Austria, PKP in Poland etc etc. Either you are ignorant of rail operations elsewhere in Europe, or you are deliberately misrepresenting the situation. Which is it?

Add your comment

 

rail technology magazine tv

more videos >

latest rail news

ECI-2 reveals key areas to embrace change to deliver Digital Railway

21/07/2017ECI-2 reveals key areas to embrace change to deliver Digital Railway

The Digital Railway has taken another step forward this week as bosses responsible for delivering the transformative project have unveiled how th... more >
New bi-mode fleet a requirement for East Midlands as consultation opens

21/07/2017New bi-mode fleet a requirement for East Midlands as consultation opens

The DfT has this week launched its public consultation on the new East Midlands franchise, including specifications for a new bi-mode fleet of in... more >
Grayling throws three major electrification plans out the window 

20/07/2017Grayling throws three major electrification plans out the window 

The government has decided to call off plans to electrify a string of major routes based on the premise that bi-mode trains already provide seaml... more >

editor's comment

03/07/2017Rapid progress needed

As RTM went to press, the National Infrastructure Commission outlined a list of the ‘top 12’ immediate priorities on which ministers must make rapid progress in the next year. Unsurprisingly, major rail schemes, including HS2, Crossrail 2 and HS3, featured highly in the projects that needed speedy development.  Lord Adonis stated that all of these have been agreed in principle, “but require decisive action to get ... read more >

last word

How do tram and rail passengers compare?

How do tram and rail passengers compare?

David Sidebottom, director at Transport Focus, analyses the drivers in performance of passenger satisfaction in tram compared to rail. Results published in our recent Tram Passenger Survey (... more > more last word articles >

'the sleepers' daily blog

Was the HS2 route decision for Sheffield correct?

21/07/2017Was the HS2 route decision for Sheffield correct?

This week has been a busy one for HS2. A number of important announcements were made by Chris Grayling, who will surely be glad to head off on holiday for some rest and relaxation as Parliament heads into its summer recess. Major details of £6.6bn worth of construction contracts were announced, as well as a pair of shortlists for HS... more >
read more blog posts from 'the sleeper' >

comment

How can the new government support rail freight?

20/07/2017How can the new government support rail freight?

Following the recent general election, Maggie Simpson, executive director at the Rail Freight Group, considers what action the government can tak... more >
Building a sustainable future for rail services in Wales

20/07/2017Building a sustainable future for rail services in Wales

Geoff Ogden, interim managing director at Transport for Wales (TfW), talks to RTM about how the organisation is putting sustainable development a... more >
A potential benchmark for engineering quality and architectural design

20/07/2017A potential benchmark for engineering quality and architectural design

Victoria Hills, chief executive officer at the Old Oak and Park Royal Development Corporation (OPDC), gives RTM an update on the work to create a... more >
Simple changes for energy efficiency

20/07/2017Simple changes for energy efficiency

Michelle Papayannakos, rail sustainability specialist at the RSSB, argues that improving the way energy is managed should be a high priority for ... more >

rail industry focus

View all News

interviews

A game changer for Wales and Borders

17/07/2017A game changer for Wales and Borders

Andy Thomas, managing director for Network Rail’s Wales route, describes how the infrastructure owner will work more collaboratively than e... more >