Rail jobs, staff issues and training

22.12.16

Court of Appeal defends Aslef’s ‘fundamental’ right to strike

The Court of Appeal has now published its reasons for refusing Govia Thameslink Railway’s (GTR’s) appeal against the High Court’s decision not to grant an injunction against Aslef’s right to take strike action over the issue of DOO trains, a decision which led to turmoil for Southern Rail last week.

GTR claimed the industrial action would be in breach of Articles 49 and 56 of European Union law, particularly in relation to the ability of persons to travel to or from EU countries due to the impact that strike action would have on Southern’s services to Gatwick Airport.

However, the Court of Appeal’s final decision defended the High Court ruling, saying that finding for GTR would “fundamentally undermine” Aslef’s right to industrial action, even if it were legitimate to dispute the form of the strike.

“It is not possible in this case to say, in advance of the action being taken, with respect to any individual passenger, that his or her ability to travel to or from the EU will be interfered with,” Lord Justice Elias wrote in his justification of the Court of Appeal’s ruling on 12 December.

“Moreover, it would undermine the right to strike in a most fundamental way if all passengers potentially and indirectly affected by the strike could claim that it was interfering with their rights to provide and receive services.

“Whether the strike is or is not proportionate, there are no legal grounds on which GTR is entitled to an injunction to block it.”

GTR argued that because the company is 35% owned by the French company Keolis SA, Aslef’s attempts to strike interfered with Keolis SA’s right to establish further enterprises in this country, an argument which was previously rejected by the High Court and upheld by the Court of Appeal.

The Court of Appeal also agreed that the impact on passengers using Gatwick was “indirect and uncertain” because they could get to Gatwick by other means. The Court said that allowing GTR’s argument would positively discriminate towards rail operators whose routes were near international passenger terminals against those that didn’t.

Commenting on the publication of the details of the judgement Aslef general secretary Mick Whelan said: “I am obviously pleased the judge refused GTR’s argument that the strike constitutes an unlawful interference with the right of establishment conferred by article 49 of the Treaty and the right to provide and receive services under article 56.

“Aslef has faced legal challenges from GTR since April of this year. This shows that the company has not been prepared to seriously address our concerns and has instead turned to the courts rather than sitting down to negotiate. The fact the company is still pursuing legal avenues rather than addressing our safety concerns makes me question their commitment to resolving this dispute.”

Aslef’s next drivers’ strike alongside the already striking RMT is set to last a full week from Monday 9 to Saturday 14 January, leaving leaders with little time to come to a compromise over the festive period. Previous discussions between Aslef and GTR at the conciliation service Acas in an attempt to resolve the dispute broke down without agreement last week.

Comments

Neil Palmer   22/12/2016 at 16:40

Lumps of coal in the Christmas stockings for RMT & ASLEF.

Lutz   22/12/2016 at 19:58

GTR: Must try harder; Get these strikes blocked.

Add your comment

 

rail technology magazine tv

more videos >

latest rail news

Reasons to be cheerful

23/03/2017Reasons to be cheerful

Ahead of the major imminent reforms to the apprenticeship system, Simon Rennie, general manager of the National Training Academy for Rail, outlin... more >
TfWM to take over running of Midland Metro next year

22/03/2017TfWM to take over running of Midland Metro next year

Day-to-day running of the Midland Metro tram service will be taken on entirely by Transport for West Midlands (TfWM) from October 2018 when the c... more >
Forgetful passengers to be refunded railcard penalties

22/03/2017Forgetful passengers to be refunded railcard penalties

A new scheme will allow passengers who are charged extra for travelling without a railcard to claim their money back at least once per year, effe... more >

editor's comment

08/03/2017A celebration of rail achievement

Welcome to this special UK Rail Industry Awards (UKRIA) review issue of RTM. The fourth edition of the prestigious awards took place on 9 February at London’s Battersea Evolution and, once again, was a huge success.  With over 1,100 rail decision-makers in attendance, the black-tie event was a great place for networking and celebrating the success of the rail industry in the last 12 months. To see who won at this year’s... read more >

last word

Reasons to be cheerful

Reasons to be cheerful

Ahead of the major imminent reforms to the apprenticeship system, Simon Rennie, general manager of the National Training Academy for Rail, outlines the industry’s reasons to be positive abo... more > more last word articles >

'the sleeper's' daily blog

Business as usual: Vivarail begins testing of new battery train

21/03/2017Business as usual: Vivarail begins testing of new battery train

If you were one of the many left saddened and disappointed when Vivarail’s test train caught fire over the festive period due to a fuel leak on one of the gensets, the company has some good news: its new test car, operated as a battery train, has completed its first successful run – sending a clear message to all non-believers that the D-Train is here to stay. As Vivarail CEO Adrian Shooter wrote in the last issue of RTM, th... more >
read more blog posts from 'the sleeper' >

comment

The future connected rail system needs a connected community

21/03/2017The future connected rail system needs a connected community

The rail and tech sectors must collaborate to determine the optimal route to the digital railway, writes Julian McGougan, head of technology at t... more >
Suppliers offer boost to digital railway plans

21/03/2017Suppliers offer boost to digital railway plans

David Clarke, technical director at the Railway Industry Association (RIA), explains why the success of the supply chain will be the success of t... more >
Collecting safety culture data confidentially

21/03/2017Collecting safety culture data confidentially

Chris Langer, scheme intelligence manager at CIRAS, explains how confidential reporting can ‘deep dive’ into an organisation’s ... more >
Inclusive design of ticket sales counters

21/03/2017Inclusive design of ticket sales counters

Boaz Yariv, senior architect, and Dr Elizabeth de Mello, senior ergonomics specialist at Network Rail, discuss the complex ergonomic consideratio... more >

rail industry focus

View all News

interviews

Intertrain: ready for the future

23/02/2017Intertrain: ready for the future

RTM recently attended Intertrain’s ‘Driving for Success’ event in Doncaster, where leaders from major players such as Carillion... more >