Rail Industry Focus

05.05.17

Railway costs through the roof?

lord tony berkeleyLord Berkeley, chairman of the Rail Freight Group, gives his thoughts on the National Audit Office’s (NAO’s) recent report into modernising Great Western Main Line (GWML) and the escalating costs of the project.

The recently published NAO report on ‘Modernising the Great Western Railway’ made depressing reading for those who want a cost-effective and growing railway. The cost of electrifying the GWML from Paddington to Swansea and Bristol has risen from £800m to probably £4.2bn, although the government tries to obfuscate these figures by reducing the scope and lately arguing that, since all the IEP trains will now have diesel motors in them, some of the original sections to be wired can be omitted with minimal effect on performance. 

However, adding diesel motors comes at a price, not included in these estimates. It is understood that there was a cost of adding diesels as an optional extra on the original order; it was X million per train if ordered before September 2014, and perhaps 5X if ordered later. So even though it was obvious well before then that the wires would not be up in time for the delivery of the trains, the DfT waited until months later to change the order, paying 5X instead of X. 

Why have the costs rocketed to this extent? There are many reasons: DfT changing its mind on the specification or scope, and telling Network Rail to make the change but not put it on the budget as an extra; ‘leave it until later when ministers and officials will have moved on!’.  Network Rail also did not know its asset in enough detail to design it effectively, and seemed to forget that it would need several thousand permissions for work not covered by permitted development rights. 

Worst of all, with a Regulatory Asset Base (AKA a limitless credit card) there was no incentive to price work effectively, or to ensure keeping to budget. The result is a serious lack of expertise in basic costing and estimating within the company. Much of this happened on Simon Kirby’s watch; he then moved to HS2 where, perhaps unsurprisingly, the same inability to estimate costs is more than evident; expert QS Michael Byng costed HS2’s design of Euston station and subsequently the whole of phase 1, and has demonstrated to HS2, officials and ministers that the cost is £48bn and not £24bn. This means that, since the “government remains committed to delivering HS2 within this funding envelope” of the £55.7bn, of which £7bn is for rolling stock, there will be no HS2 beyond Birmingham and Hansacre unless the Treasury finds some more money. 

The problem is not just about underestimating, because there are many examples of where Network Rail has quoted such high costs of enhancements, perhaps for fear of pricing too low, that the project does not go ahead. I am not, of course, blaming Kirby personally; the problem goes back many years in a failure of governance both in Network Rail and the DfT, who after all have to sanction expenditure by Network Rail. The real issue is that neither Network Rail nor HS2 know how to estimate properly. 

What are the possible solutions? 

We have to find them since, otherwise, enhancements or new works will not happen. Ministers are clearly fed up with all this and are encouraging the industry to challenge costs, and come up with alternative structures for developing new or upgraded lines. East West Rail is a good example, but how much liberty will the new team led by Rob Brighouse be allowed in designing, getting permissions, building and operating a line separately from Network Rail? Will they be allowed to avoid the ridiculously expensive and time-consuming GRIP process beloved by those in Network Rail wedded to process rather than progress?    

Why shouldn’t sponsors and financiers prepare a three-page specification and put it out to competitive tender for design, get permissions, build and operate the infrastructure? An early example of this may be March to Wisbech reopening, where such an approach might save 30% of the cost estimated by Network Rail. 

Beyond all this is the need for a number of estimators who know how to do it, trained to use the RMM suite of railway cost measurement commissioned by Network Rail from Michael Byng but sadly not yet adopted by them.   

Let us see a ‘can-do’ approach to change and improvement, always asking the question  ‘can it be done cheaper or better or quicker’ rather than starting with the old railway response to anything new: ‘well, there are 25 reasons why this will not work or cannot be done’ and ‘it’s more than my job’s worth!’

Comments

Robin   06/06/2017 at 18:16

More power to your elbow, Lord Berkeley! I'm delighted that at long last someone is pointing out that railway civil engineering costs and signalling costs have gone through the roof - suspiciously so, in my opinion. I'm not convinced it's all due to ignorance and incompetence. There may be a more sinister explanation.

Duncan Stewart   24/07/2017 at 12:57

"...several thousand permissions for work not covered by permitted development rights. " That seems very odd. Granted that planning may have tightened since the west and east coast elecrifications,but I have the strong feeling that Network Rail is making applications for which they do have permitted rights if they did but know it. If they did but know it ... And there's the rub. Fundamentally NR have exhibited incompetence (that is they are not competent). which begs lots more questions.

Add your comment

 

related

rail technology magazine tv

more videos >

latest rail news

View all News

rail industry focus

View all News

editor's comment

23/01/2018Out with the old...

Despite a few disappointing policy announcements, especially for the electrification aficionados amongst us, 2017 was, like Darren Caplan writes on page 20, a year generally marked by positive news for the rail industry. We polished off the iconic Ordsall Chord (p32), hit some solid milestones on Thameslink (p40), progressed on ambitious rolling stock orders (p16), and finally started moving forward on HS2 (p14) ‒ paving the way for a New Year with brand-new infrastructrure to... read more >

last word

Encouraging youngsters to be safe on the railway

Encouraging youngsters to be safe on the railway

This summer, Arriva Group's CrossCountry and the Scout Association joined to launch a new partnership to promote rail safety among young people. Chris Leech MBE, business community manager at the TOC, gives RTM an update on the innovative scheme. Recognising that young people are more likely to take a risk trespassing on railway tracks, C... more > more last word articles >

interviews

Andrew Haines, CE of Network Rail, tells BBC News his organisation could issue future rail franchises

24/06/2019Andrew Haines, CE of Network Rail, tells BBC News his organisation could issue future rail franchises

By Ewan Quayle, Rail Technology Magazine Reporter Andrew Haines, the Chief Executive of Ne... more >

'the sleepers' daily blog

Apprentice to Co-leading the Rail Sector Deal

05/06/2019Apprentice to Co-leading the Rail Sector Deal

In a series of Q&A’s with key speakers on the run up to TransCityRail Midlands, we caught up with TransCityRail panellist and Amey’s commercial account director, Anna Delvecchio, for her insight into what the Rail Sector Deal means for the rail industry and its supply chain. Anna started her career as an apprentice at the age o... more >
read more blog posts from 'the sleeper' >

comment

The challenge of completing Crossrail

05/07/2019The challenge of completing Crossrail

With a new plan now in place to deliver Crossrail, Hedley Ayres, National Audit Office manager, major projects and programmes, takes a look at ho... more >
Preparing the industry to deliver trains for the future

04/07/2019Preparing the industry to deliver trains for the future

The move to decarbonise the rail network involves shifting to cleaner modes of traction by 2050. David Clarke, technical director at the Railway ... more >
Sunshine future beckons for South Wales Railways, says 10:10 Climate Action’s Leo Murray

02/07/2019Sunshine future beckons for South Wales Railways, says 10:10 Climate Action’s Leo Murray

Smart electrification is the way to boost clean energy resources, argues Leo Murray, director at 10:10 Climate Action. Contractors are clear... more >
Ambition doesn’t have to be expensive, says Midland Connect's Maria Machancoses

02/07/2019Ambition doesn’t have to be expensive, says Midland Connect's Maria Machancoses

The TCR Midlands conference is only days away and tickets are going fast for the sector event of the year at the Vox Conference Centre in Birming... more >