Inbox

25.03.15

Government yet to make ‘convincing case’ for HS2 – Lords report

The government has not yet made a “convincing case” for the £50bn HS2 railway, a report from the House of Lords Economic Affairs Select Committee has concluded. 

It was noted that the government has based its justification for HS2 on two factors: increased rail capacity and rebalancing the UK economy. But the Committee says it has not seen evidence “that it is the best way to deliver either”. 

On capacity, full information on railway usage has not been made publicly available by the government, on the grounds of commercial sensitivity, the Committee noted. 

Also, evidence shows that long-distance trains arriving at and departing from Euston are, on average, just 43% full and even during peak times are only between 50 and 60% full. 

Lord Hollick, chairman of the Committee, said: “At £50bn HS2 will be one of the most expensive infrastructure projects ever undertaken in the UK but the government have not yet made a convincing case for why it is necessary. 

“Overcrowding on the West Coast Main Line is largely a problem on commuter trains and on long-distance trains immediately after peak time on Friday evenings and at some weekends. The government have not carried out a proper assessment of whether alternative ways of increasing capacity are more cost effective than HS2.” 

But the Department for Transport (DfT) has claimed that the case for HS2 is “crystal clear”. 

“It will have a transformational effect, supporting growth in the north by improving connectivity, freeing up space on our crowded rail network, promoting regeneration, boosting local skills, generating tens of thousands of jobs and helping secure the UK’s future prosperity,” said a DfT spokesperson. 

“It is a vital part of the government’s long-term economic plan, strongly supported by northern and midland cities, alongside our plans for better east-west rail links confirmed in the Northern Transport Strategy last week.” 

The Committee agrees with the objective to rebalance the economy but disputes the claim that HS2 is the way to achieve it. In particular, they claim London would most likely be the biggest beneficiary from HS2. 

It was argued that there is a strong case for improving the trans-Pennine links or building the northern legs of HS2 first, both of which could be a better way of rebalancing the economy than building the southern leg of HS2. 

On cost, the Committee says that the cost per mile of HS2 is estimated to be up to nine times higher than the cost of constructing high-speed lines in France. The Committee suggests that, if HS2 is to go ahead, the cost could be reduced by building it to run at 200mph, as in Europe, instead of 250mph, terminating the line at Old Oak Common or learning lessons from France to reduce the cost of construction. 

In addition, the report suggests that the public subsidy to HS2, an estimated net £31.5bn, conflicts with the government's declared objective of making rail less dependent on public subsidy. 

A DfT spokesperson said: “We have been fully transparent about the project. HS2 will deliver over £2 of benefits for every £1 invested and the economic benefit of the project was recognised by MPs of all parties who voted 452 to 41 in favour of HS2 at the second reading of the Hybrid Bill. 

“Their strong support is shared by the Transport Select Committee which backs the strategic business case and is confident that HS2 is the only practical way to significantly increase rail capacity.” 

However, Lord Hollick said that the report sets out a number of important questions on HS2 that the government must now provide detailed answers to.  

For example, the committee wants to know whether the funding envelope of £50bn for the cost of construction is an absolute limit or will it increase with inflation. Also, should passengers benefiting from faster journeys on HS2 pay premium fares to reduce the high level of taxpayer subsidy of the project? This is something Alison Munro, managing director in charge of developing HS2, said won’t happen at RTM’s High Speed 2 The Northern Hub dinner

“Parliament should not approve the enabling legislation that will allow HS2 work to begin until we have satisfactory answers to these key questions,” added Lord Hollick. 

Responding to the report, a spokesperson for the High Speed Rail Industry Leaders commented: “HS2 has been subject to more debate and analysis than any infrastructure project we have ever seen before. This national debate has resulted in widespread national consensus and clear public opinion in favour of the project. 

“HS2 will transform Britain. It will power the economy by creating thousands of jobs, of which 70% will be outside London. It will bring our great cities closer together, and stimulate regeneration across the country, just as high speed rail has already transformed King’s Cross. 

“The industry delivers similar projects all over the world already. We are ready, willing and able to deliver HS2.” 

Tell us what you think – have your say below or email opinion@railtechnologymagazine.com 

Comments

Peter   27/03/2015 at 12:51

How can the dft keep saying these things in response to reasoned criticism. The £2 return for every £1 invested has long been downgraded and as for 'clear public opinion in favour of the project' - which member of the public was that ?

Add your comment

 

related

rail technology magazine tv

more videos >

latest rail news

Rail Industry Ambassadors set to help shape the future of rail

11/11/2019Rail Industry Ambassadors set to help shape the future of rail

Young Rail Professionals have announced in support of their mission to promote the rail industry as a great place to work, they’re recruiti... more >
Amulet wins PFM award for work with C2C

11/11/2019Amulet wins PFM award for work with C2C

Amulet, the specialist security business of the Churchill group has won the Partners in Expert Services – Public Sector for its partnership... more >
Great Western Railway makes Jack’s railway dreams come true

08/11/2019Great Western Railway makes Jack’s railway dreams come true

Jack Thompson wished to be a ‘Station Master’ for the day and train operator Great Western Railway (GWR) made it a reality. GWR ... more >
100 years after first memorial service, South Western Railway worker pays respect to his great-grandfather

08/11/2019100 years after first memorial service, South Western Railway worker pays respect to his great-grandfather

Team member at Putney station, Matthew Philips, has a special connection to the railway. His great-grandfather worked on the same rail route, whi... more >

editor's comment

23/01/2018Out with the old...

Despite a few disappointing policy announcements, especially for the electrification aficionados amongst us, 2017 was, like Darren Caplan writes on page 20, a year generally marked by positive news for the rail industry. We polished off the iconic Ordsall Chord (p32), hit some solid milestones on Thameslink (p40), progressed on ambitious rolling stock orders (p16), and finally started moving forward on HS2 (p14) ‒ paving the way for a New Ye... read more >

last word

Encouraging youngsters to be safe on the railway

Encouraging youngsters to be safe on the railway

This summer, Arriva Group's CrossCountry and the Scout Association joined to launch a new partnership to promote rail safety among young people. Chris Leech MBE, business community manager at the TOC, gives RTM an update on the innovative scheme... more > more last word articles >

interviews

Andrew Haines, CE of Network Rail, tells BBC News his organisation could issue future rail franchises

24/06/2019Andrew Haines, CE of Network Rail, tells BBC News his organisation could issue future rail franchises

Andrew Haines, the Chief Executive of Network Rail, has told the Today programme on Radio 4's BBC’s flagship news programme that he wo... more >

the sleeper's daily blog

NPR, TRU & Fleetwood Mac

18/10/2019NPR, TRU & Fleetwood Mac

Switch up your playlist with the first #WeAreRTM podcast, gain exclusive insight into the leaders running the rail industry their opinions on recent headlines, visions for the future and meet the personalities behind the job titles. It's not your average interview. Anna-Jane Hunter, Network Rail’s director, North of England rai... more >
read more blog posts from 'the sleeper' >

comment

The challenge of completing Crossrail

05/07/2019The challenge of completing Crossrail

With a new plan now in place to deliver Crossrail, Hedley Ayres, National Audit Office manager, major projects and programmes, takes a look at ho... more >
Preparing the industry to deliver trains for the future

04/07/2019Preparing the industry to deliver trains for the future

The move to decarbonise the rail network involves shifting to cleaner modes of traction by 2050. David Clarke, technical director at the Railway ... more >
Sunshine future beckons for South Wales Railways, says 10:10 Climate Action’s Leo Murray

02/07/2019Sunshine future beckons for South Wales Railways, says 10:10 Climate Action’s Leo Murray

Smart electrification is the way to boost clean energy resources, argues Leo Murray, director at 10:10 Climate Action. Contractors are clear... more >
Ambition doesn’t have to be expensive, says Midland Connect's Maria Machancoses

02/07/2019Ambition doesn’t have to be expensive, says Midland Connect's Maria Machancoses

The TCR Midlands conference is only days away and tickets are going fast for the sector event of the year at the Vox Conference Centre in Birming... more >

rail industry focus

  • 02/11/2019Monica Barbosa: Women In Rail

    Director of business development and communications at Xrail, Monica Barbosa, thinks women are missing out on exciting opportunities because the...
  • 01/11/2019The dangers of fatigues

    Working long hours, poor health, too little sleep, a demanding job and more can all make us tired and affect our mental and physical performance...
  • 01/11/2019Mind the skills gap

    Working long hours, poor health, too little sleep, a demanding job and more can all make us tired and affect our mental and physical performance...
View all News