Where next for a rail investment plan in the north?

Lord Tony Berkeley, chair of the Rail Freight Group, analyses the potential impact of major government announcements regarding pan-north electrification and CP6 funding.

In the last few months we have been subjected to a barrage of ministerial announcements about the railways in and around the Northern Powerhouse area. Maybe the penny is now dropping in Whitehall that the commitments made by George Osborne before the election need to be enhanced and delivered.

It all started with the Conservative Party manifesto of May 2016, which stated that they “are investing to reduce travel time and cost, increase capacity and attract investment” including via HS2 and Northern Powerhouse Rail, “and we will ensure that these great projects do as much as possible to develop the skills and careers of British workers.” Fine words, but it was only a few weeks after the election that many electrification projects were effectively cancelled. Grayling wrote to me, and no doubt other peers, saying passengers will benefit from this since “new train fuelling technology that is as revolutionary as anything now being deployed in the car industry” will “transform the way passengers experience our railways.”

Then later, DfT announced that they would give the Northern Powerhouse £5m to develop a digital railway and, in September, the transport secretary stated that “there has been no change whatsoever to the electrification plans for the TransPennine route.”

Finally, on 11 October, the government announced the Statement of Funds Available (SoFA) for Network Rail over the next five-year control period. The eight-page document quoted a figure for Network Rail expenditure of £47.9bn and a network grant of £34.7bn; helpfully, four pages were blank so we don’t have a clue what the money will be spent on! 

We do know, however, that it is apparently the government’s view that revolutionary bi-mode trains using electric power (presumably only on the uphill sections) are cheaper, more comfortable, faster and therefore better for passenger comfort. Most industry experts think the opposite, and deplore the cancellation of so many of the electrification plans which will, no doubt, mean a loss of many good people from the industry, higher costs and lower capacity because the bi-modes cannot accelerate as fast under diesel power.

Worse still, all upgrades will be controlled from Whitehall. The DfT plans to come up with new procedures to authorise enhancements which will be funded separately, as is HS2. Separate funding does not preclude talking to each other; it is time that HS2 properly engaged with NR routes and customers – but then, HS2 is controlled by a separate silo within DfT!   

How routes can help

So, the question now is ‘can Network Rail deliver?’ A good part of the SoFA is for improved maintenance and renewals, as well as completing work held over from CP5. The pressures on the company are very high at present, in light of the delays and cost overruns, coupled with uncertainty within the organisation as to whether the routes or the centre will have the final say on what is done, how much it will cost and who is in charge.

It must be hoped that the routes can bring not only local knowledge, often missing at the DfT, but also local delivery, leaving Network Rail’s IP department with just a few major cross-route projects. The benefit of this is that it will incentivise routes to bring innovative ideas, competition and customer benefits, and their performance to be assessed by the ORR. The routes are reported to be keen as mustard to get on with this, but the centre is fighting back.

Competition between routes, not just on train performance but on delivery of maintenance, renewals and enhancements, can only be good for the industry in getting costs down and keeping the network open longer for its customers. Can this be the start of a competitive ‘can-do’ approach across the industry?

Top Image: coldsnowstorm


Graham   02/11/2017 at 17:51

Having read what Lord Berkeley has said I am in total agreement the only points I would add are that we scrap the MoT and let the French electrify the entire network as the saving of the incompetent peoples pay at the MoT would be more than enough to electrify the whole network and build the power stations to power it

Noam   03/11/2017 at 10:53

I doubt 'cancelling' [ie postponing] these schemes will result in the loss of many people. They were cancelled because the existing GWML scheme is sucking in huge amounts of money, time and people. These people will simply move onto the new schemes once GWML is completed and other schemes on the MML, Cardiff-Swansea, Windermere and elsewhere are 'un-postponed'.

John Webster   04/11/2017 at 19:10

I can't see the Windermere Branch being "un-postponed" when Northern will soon be taking delivery of Class 769 bi-modes!

Andrew Gwilt   05/11/2017 at 19:33

Well that’s why the North of England needs more trains and more trains needed means more services to operate across the North of England including the Transpennine routes and also connecting cities including Manchester, Leeds, Bradford, Sheffield, York, Hull, Liverpool, Preston, Bolton, Middlesbrough, Carlisle, Newcastle, Sunderland, Durham and other towns and cities in the North of England to rely on trains for people to travel from A to B by rail. Aswell as improving major and minor roads in the North of England as part of the Northern Powerhouse scheme.

Add your comment


rail technology magazine tv

more videos >

latest rail news

View all News

rail industry focus

Testing tomorrow's technology today

09/11/2017Testing tomorrow's technology today

David Brazier, site manager and area sales ma... more >
What next for safety?

09/11/2017What next for safety?

As rail businesses edge towards their target ... more >

editor's comment

04/09/2017A series of incredible events

There are a couple of announcements I’d like to make in this editor’s comment, which I believe could be very beneficial to many of our readers.  Firstly, the deadline is fast approaching to enter the UK Rail Industry Awards (UKRIA), which will take place on 22 March 2018 at Battersea Evolution in London.  Now in its fifth year, UKRIA continues to bring together the leaders and decision-makers running the rail industry for the sector’s biggest and most... read more >

last word

Encouraging youngsters to be safe on the railway

Encouraging youngsters to be safe on the railway

This summer, Arriva Group's CrossCountry and the Scout Association joined to launch a new partnership to promote rail safety among young people. Chris Leech MBE, business community manager at the TOC, gives RTM an update on the innovative scheme. Recognising that young people are more likely to take a risk trespassing on railway tracks, C... more > more last word articles >

'the sleepers' daily blog

Looking back over HS1, 10 years on

14/11/2017Looking back over HS1, 10 years on

While the HS2 project continues to gain ground and press ahead with major contracts despite recent staffing controversies, today sees its older, considerably smaller sibling turn 10 years old. HS1, the line running between St Pancras International and the Channel Tunnel, was completed at a total cost of £7.3bn a full 16 years after ... more >
read more blog posts from 'the sleeper' >


Modernising journeys in north east England

09/11/2017Modernising journeys in north east England

First Hull Trains is about to embark on the biggest fleet overhaul it has delivered since being set up in 2000. Managing director Will Dunnett te... more >
Ian Prosser: Safety by design

02/11/2017Ian Prosser: Safety by design

Ian Prosser, the ORR’s chief inspector of railways and director of railway safety, outlines to RTM’s Josh Mines the key challenges fa... more >
A complete step change for sleeper travel

26/10/2017A complete step change for sleeper travel

Ahead of the roll-out of new Caledonian Sleeper rolling stock next year, the company’s chairman, Peter Strachan, tells RTM’s Josh Min... more >
Taking the alliance to the next level

26/10/2017Taking the alliance to the next level

Source: RTM Oct/Nov 17 Five months after taking over the top job at ScotRail Alliance, managing director Alex Hynes speaks to RTM’s Lu... more >